Why is selective cutting less damaging to the environment than clear cutting?

Asked By: Sadrac Pliego | Last Updated: 20th March, 2020
Category: business and finance environmental services industry
4.7/5 (761 Views . 13 Votes)
Why is selective cutting less damaging to the environment than clear cutting? selective cutting removes single trees or a relatively small number if trees from the larger forest thus making it less damaging to the environment by taking out less trees.

Click to see full answer


Just so, what is the benefit of harvesting trees by selective cutting rather than clear cutting?

Clear-cutting is usually quicker and cheaper than selective cutting. It may also be safer for the loggers. Clear-cutting can damage the environment and the soil where the trees were cut. The soil is exposed to wind and rain.

Also, why are rangelands so fragile Why do we continue to heavily use them despite their fragility? They are semi arid, which makes them more likely to be disturbed. We need the land to raise cattle.

One may also ask, why might selective logging be preferable to clear cutting?

Selective logging—the practice of removing one or two trees and leaving the rest intact—is often considered a sustainable alternative to clear-cutting, in which a large swath of forest is cut down, leaving little behind except wood debris and a denuded landscape.

Why do Vines increase the damage to a forest done by selective cutting?

The presence of vines interconnecting the canopies of tropical forest trees has been thought to increase the damage to neighboring trees when a tree is felled during selective logging, resulting in larger canopy gaps and possibly prejudicting future timber harvests.

25 Related Question Answers Found

Who does clear cutting positive impact?

Clearcutting pros: It creates wide, open spaces with lots of sun exposure. This allows the most sunlight to reach tree seedlings that require full-sun conditions to thrive. Clearcutting also creates forest clearings that are habitat for some species of songbirds, deer and elk.

Is clear cutting sustainable?

Clear cutting is not necessary, nor is it practical. Logging should instead be done using methods that create sustainable yield--which ensures that no more is harvested than can be naturally replenished (Dadd).

Is selective cutting expensive?

With selective cutting, only some of the trees in an area of forest are cut down at any one time. Selective cutting takes longer, is more expensive, and can be dangerous for loggers working in tight spaces, however, it preserves topsoil and does not expose soil to erosion or streams to sedimentation.

What are two negative environmental impacts of clear cutting?

Clearcutting Impacts
Negatively impacts water quality and quantity – Clearcutting and the logging roads created to service clearcuts can increase erosion of sediments into creeks and rivers, clouding waters and reducing water quality for fish habitat and human consumption.

What is clear cutting advantages and disadvantages?


What Are Some Advantages & Disadvantages of Clear Cutting?
  • Pro: Financial Reasons. Clearcutting advocates argue that the method is the most efficient for both harvesting and replanting trees.
  • Con: Effects on Plant and Wildlife.
  • Pro: Increased Water Flow.
  • Con: Loss of Recreation Land.
  • Pro: Increased Farmland.

What are the disadvantages of selective cutting?

Some of the disadvantages are that some species may not regenerate quickly, and thinning the forest may lead to increased damage from ice, storms or fires. One of the biggest advantages of selective cutting is that the overall ecological impact on the forest is reduced.

Is clear cutting good or bad?

Clearcuts can be beneficial to wildlife.
Clearcutting increases the biological diversity of the forest, which enhances the habitat for a variety of wildlife. Some species of wildlife actually thrive better in brushy thickets of seedlings and small saplings.

What are 3 Consequences of clear cutting?

Clearcutting may lead to increased stream flow during storms, loss of habitat and species diversity, opportunities for invasive and weedy species, and negative impacts on scenery, as well as a decrease in property values; diminished recreation, hunting, and fishing opportunities.

Is selective cutting good?

Selective Cutting as a Tool of Sustainable Forestry
When practiced correctly, selective cutting has the following benefits. Removes trees that are low quality while they are young. Removes some of the profitable mature growth. Allows more light to penetrate the upper story of growth.

Where is selective cutting used?


Heavy machinery is used, leaving sections between the strips uncut, especially among lakes and rivers to reduce soil and limit wind erosion. Selective cutting means to go in and harvest only a limited amount of trees that meet a certain criteria. This usually happens in multi-species forests.

What is the purpose of logging?

Logging. Logging is the process of cutting and processing trees to produce timber and pulp to supply the world's markets for furniture, construction, paper, and other products. The practice of logging ranges from large-scale commercial timber plantations to individuals harvesting fuelwood.

How is selective logging and replanting sustainable?

Selective logging and replanting,
Selective logging is more sustainable than clear-cutting because other trees and plants do survive in the logging process and over time can allow the forest to recover. Although single trees are felled because they are valuable, other trees can be damaged in the process.

What does selective cutting mean?

Selective cutting is the cutting down of selected trees in a forest so that growth of other trees is not affected. This is done according to criteria regarding minimum tree size for harvesting, specifications of the number, spacing and size classes of residual trees per area, and allowable cut.

Where does selective logging happen?

Selective logging is a dominant form of land use in the Brazilian Amazon. Canopy gap fractions patterns are found to result from selective logging caused tree falls, roads, skid trails, and log decks, which are areas where logs are staged for transport. These gaps can vary between logging operations.

What does clear cutting a forest mean?


Definition of clear-cutting. : the removal of all the trees in an area of forest Long considered a "trash tree" by the timber industry, the number of Pacific yews has been drastically reduced—perhaps halved—by clear-cutting, the logging practice that totally strips a targeted area.—

Are destructive methods always natural?

Are these destructive methods always natural? Explain your answer. Human activity may alter or "deflect the natural course of succession, which leads to a change in the climax community. An example of a human activity that deflects succession would be grass mowing.

Why is selective logging bad?

Selective logging causes long-term changes to forest structure. Selective logging is causing long-term changes to tropical forests in Africa by facilitating the growth of weeds and vines, which reduces plant diversity and diminishes carbon storage, reports a new paper published in the journal Ecological Research.