Which is better aerator or spike aerator?

Asked By: Asmahane Llordes | Last Updated: 9th April, 2020
Category: business and finance green solutions
4.9/5 (326 Views . 38 Votes)
Core aerators are the only way to go. They lessen soil compaction and promote better root growth. Spike aerators are cheaper but they increase soil compaction and don't really accomplish much. It's not the equipment that makes a professional, it's the operator.

Click to see full answer


In respect to this, which is better plug aerator or spike aerator?

Spike and plug aerators are used to alleviate the negative affects of compacted soil on your lawn. Plug aerators are usually more effective at relieving compaction in lawns with a heavy clay soil since the solid tines used on spike aerators compact the clay soil further when they push into the ground.

Similarly, which type of aerator is best? Here are Our Top Picks:

Features
Best OverallYard Butler Lawn AeratorBest Overall Extremely Affordable Manual Step Aeration Good for Small Spaces Check Current Price
Agri-Fab 48-Inch Tow Plug AeratorBest Machine 48" Wide Aeration Path Plug-Style Aerator Good for Large Lawns Check Current Price

Also asked, is a spike aerator good?

The Spike Aerator Spike aerating is a good method, although it doesn't give you the deep holes of a plug aerating option, it does allow for much more even coverage. Also, spike aerating means that the grass seed being placed won't wash away if it's set on an incline surface.

How do you use a spike aerator?

With a spike aerator, you simply use the tool to poke holes into the ground with a solid tine, or fork. Plug aerators remove a core or plug of grass and soil from the lawn. For the best results, use an aerating tool or machine that actually removes plugs of soil.

30 Related Question Answers Found

Should I pick up plugs after aerating?

Some lawns need aerating every year, although most can go two to three years before needing aerating -- which is good, if you don't like the look of brown plugs on your lawn. You don't have to rake the plugs left by aerating, but doing so gets nutrients back into the soil faster.

Can you aerate too much?

Loose soil doesn't need to be aerated very often. Especially thick types of grass may also call for aerating more frequently. As a general rule, you shouldn't need to aerate more than once a year at any time ("too much of a good thing" applies here, since you don't want to damage your soil).

Can I mow right after aerating?

You mow too soon.
They'll need to acclimate and set roots before the first mow, so during the first two to four weeks post aerating and overseeding, don't mow. Once the grass reaches about three to three and half inches, you can fire up the mower for a fresh cut.

Should I mow before or after aeration?

Mow the lawn before you aerate it. Don't mow the lawn for at least a week after aerating it. Make sure you know where all your sprinklers and pop-ups are otherwise you might damage them. It's a good idea to water the lawn before aerating it because aeration is most effective when the soil is slightly moist.

What do you do after you aerate your yard?


What to Do After Aerating Your Lawn
  1. Leave the soil plugs on the lawn to decompose and filter back into the holes left by the aeration machine.
  2. Apply fertilizer immediately after aerating your lawn to put nutrients into your grass roots.
  3. Reseed your lawn, especially in areas of the lawn where the grass is thin.

How heavy is an aerator?

In fact, the BlueBird aerator weighs in at nearly 300 pounds – and that's without the two 36 lb. removable weights that it comes with for extra traction.

Can I aerate my lawn with a pitchfork?

Although special core aerators, which remove plugs of soil, work best, a pitchfork can work in a pinch as a simple aeration solution. Aerate only when the grass is actively growing and not dormant for the season.

Does lawn aeration really work?

Why Aerating Helps Lawns
A layer of compacted soil just 1/4 to 1/2 inches thick can make a significant difference in the health and beauty of your lawn. 1 Aeration creates holes down into the soil to alleviate compaction so air, water and nutrients can reach grass roots.

How often should I spike aerate my lawn?


Aeration should be done once a year for healthy lawns and at least twice a year for lawns with compacted soil and thatch buildup.

How often should you spike your lawn?

Spiking (2" to 6") using your lawn aerator sandals, rolling lawn aerator, garden fork, powered or towed aerators can be done at any time from March to November. Repeat as often as you like as it's very beneficial. Avoid very wet soil that smears or when frost is imminent, otherwise get stuck in.

Will aerating lawn help drainage?

Aeration: one of the best yard drainage solutions on the market is core aeration. Aerating punches holes in the lawn and adds air pockets. This will help improve air and water circulation. Just a few inches of hardpan subsoil can improve yard drainage.

How much should you aerate your lawn?

Lawn aeration removes plugs of soil from your yard, allowing for extra air and water flow — and a healthier yard as a whole. The cost to aerate a yard ranges from $74 and $190, with a national average of $126. Smaller yards may cost as low as $45 and big yards around $350.

What is the best way to aerate your lawn?

Before You Aerate
Peiffer says the best aerating machines are those with hollow, metal tines that penetrate the ground and pull plugs of soil from the lawn. You can help the tines penetrate deeper by watering your lawn one to two days prior to areating. Apply about an inch of water to the grass.

How do I aerate my lawn manually?


Push a hand aerifier, which has tube hollows that are 1/4 to 1/2 inch in diameter, or a spading fork through your lawn grass and into the soil. Pull the tool from the soil and grass, and check the soil moisture content. If soil sticks to the tool, then the soil is too wet to aerate.

How much does an aerator cost?

Keyes says he prices out aeration jobs per 1,000 square feet. He says the typical aeration job averages 5,000 square feet and costs around $110. Cellura says you can rent a lawn aerator from a toll rental shop for $40 to $80 a day, but you may spend the whole day doing it yourself.

How do you make a homemade aerator?

How to Make a Homemade Aerator for Lawns
  1. Measure and mark every 2 inches along the long sides of the 6-by-12-inch plywood.
  2. Connect the marks to make a graph on the wood, using the ruler as a straightedge.
  3. Place the plywood on a grass or dirt surface.
  4. Drive a 4-inch nail into each of the drilled holes with a hammer.