What's wrong with reductionism?

Asked By: Alan Artaça | Last Updated: 25th June, 2020
Category: medical health mental health
4/5 (53 Views . 35 Votes)
The problem with reductionism, at least as naively applied, is that it misses emergent properties of the system. Reductionism says that emergent properties are nothing more than the sum of the reduced properties applied over a very large scale.

Click to see full answer


Just so, what is an example of reductionism?

Examples of Reductionism in Biology Looking closely at DNA is a great example of reductionism. The molecule contains genes that code for physical and behavioral expressions of an organism. Another common example of reductionism in biology is the concept of development.

Furthermore, what is non reductionism? Non-reductionism is the stance that explanations can be complete at their own level and need not be justified by other levels of explanation (such as biology, or physics etc.).

Likewise, people ask, what is a reductionist argument?

If someone believes that you can break complex theories into simple, smaller parts, you can call that person a reductionist. A reductionist might explain religion, for example, as simply an attempt to explain why the world exists.

Why is reductionism useful?

Focus. One of the major benefits of reductionism is that it allows researchers to look at things that can be incredibly varied and complex such as the human mind and behavior, and break them down into smaller parts that are easier to investigate. It allows researchers to focus on a specific problem.

30 Related Question Answers Found

What is the opposite of reductionism?

The opposite of reductionism is emergentism or emergence, the view that some physical and natural properties can never be reduces to more fundamental laws. An emergentist believes that you will never be able to explain one in terms of the other. The whole is different from the sum of the parts.

What does reductionism mean in psychology?

In psychology, reductionism refers to a theory that seems to over-simplify human behavior or cognitive processes, and in doing so, neglects to explain the complexities of the mind.

Why is reductionism a weakness?

Weaknesses: Reductionist as it tries to explain complex behaviour with one influence. It doesn't consider how other factors interact together in influencing behaviour which reduces the validity of the approach/debate. Discovering that certain behaviours are inherited (e.g. personality, intelligence) may not be helpful.

What is holistic approach in psychology?

Holistic Psychology
Holism refers to any approach that emphasizes the whole rather than their constituent parts. In other words 'the whole is greater than the sum of its parts'. Qualitative methods of the humanistic approach reflect a holistic position. Social psychology also takes a holistic view.

How do you understand holism?


holism. The definition of holism is a theory suggesting that parts can only be understood in relation to the whole. An example of holism is a theory that believes you cannot break things down to study them, but instead that everything has to be understood in relation to the whole or the sum of its parts.

What is the difference between holism and reductionism?

As nouns the difference between reductionism and holism
is that reductionism is an approach to studying complex systems or ideas by reducing them to a set of simpler components while holism is a theory or belief that the whole is greater than the sum of the parts.

What is holistic theory?

Noun. 1. holistic theory - the theory that the parts of any whole cannot exist and cannot be understood except in their relation to the whole; "holism holds that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts"; "holistic theory has been applied to ecology and language and mental states" holism.

What is reductive thinking?

The reductive reasoning is a reasoning that shows a statement is true by showing that an absurd result follows from its denial.

Can biology be reduced physics?

Yes, because all biological phenomena are also physical phenomena. That is, there is no "vital principle" or any other nonsensical formulation that separates biology from physics. If you try to reduce biology to physics, you are no longer using that shortcut, and are no longer talking about biology.

Is Marxism a reductionist?


Marx wasn't a crude reductionist, but he did believe that the way in which society organized production ultimately shaped people's attitudes and beliefs.

What is cultural reductionism?

Reductionism is any of several related philosophical ideas regarding the associations between phenomena which can be described in terms of other simpler or more fundamental phenomena. Methodological reductionism: the scientific attempt to provide explanation in terms of ever smaller entities.

Who came up with reductionism?

The earliest reductionist philosopher was Thales, born around 636 BC at Miletus in Asia Minor. He hypothesized that the universe was made out of water—water being the fundamental substance of which all others were composed. Reductionism was later re-introduced by Descartes in Part V of his Discourses.

What does reduction mean in philosophy?

The term 'reduction' as used in philosophy expresses the idea that if an entity x reduces to an entity y then y is in a sense prior to x, is more basic than x, is such that x fully depends upon it or is constituted by it.

When did positivism emerge?

Auguste Comte (1798–1857) first described the epistemological perspective of positivism in The Course in Positive Philosophy, a series of texts published between 1830 and 1842. These texts were followed by the 1844 work, A General View of Positivism (published in French 1848, English in 1865).

What does determinism mean in philosophy?


Determinism, in philosophy, theory that all events, including moral choices, are completely determined by previously existing causes. Determinism is usually understood to preclude free will because it entails that humans cannot act otherwise than they do.

What is reductionism in criminology?

Reductionism is a viewpoint that regards one phenomenon as entirely explainable by the properties of another phenomenon. The first can be said to be reducible to the second. An opposite form of reductionism is sociological reductionism. This reduces psychological phenomena to epiphenomena of social factors.

What is the mind body problem in philosophy?

The mindbody problem is a debate concerning the relationship between thought and consciousness in the human mind, and the brain as part of the physical body. This question arises when mind and body are considered as distinct, based on the premise that the mind and the body are fundamentally different in nature.