What is the substantial evidence rule?

Asked By: Walton Wals | Last Updated: 15th January, 2020
Category: news and politics law
4.2/5 (41 Views . 45 Votes)
Substantial evidence rule is a principle that a reviewing court should uphold an administrative body's ruling if it is supported by evidence on which the administrative body could reasonably base its decision.

Click to see full answer


Consequently, what is the substantial evidence standard?

This standard falls between probable cause and preponderance of the evidence, and requires more than a “mere scintilla of evidence.” Substantial evidence is “such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion.” (Richardson v. Perales, 402 U.S. 389 (1971).)

Similarly, what is required by the substantial evidence test? The conclusions reached must be supported by such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion.

Furthermore, what is the substantial evidence test?

Substantial evidence is a legal concept that an individual piece of evidence is so sufficient that a reasonable person of sound mind could convict or acquit based on that one piece of evidence alone. For the courts to consider a piece of evidence as substantial, the evidence must pass the “substantial evidence test.”

What are the 3 standards of review?

Concerning constitutional questions, three basic standards of review exist: rational basis, intermediate scrutiny, and strict scrutiny. This form of standard of review is sometimes also called the standard or level of scrutiny.

34 Related Question Answers Found

What are 4 types of evidence?

The four types of evidence recognized by the courts include demonstrative, real, testimonial and documentary. The first type, demonstrative, is evidence that demonstrated the testimony given by a witness. Documentary evidence is most often considered real evidence.

What are the 3 burdens of proof?

The three primary standards of proof are proof beyond a reasonable doubt, preponderance of the evidence and clear and convincing evidence.

What percentage is clear and convincing evidence?

Under the clear and convincing standard, the evidence must be substantially greater than a 50% likelihood of being true. In a criminal trial, clear and convincing is less strict than the “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt” standard, which requires that evidence be close to certain of being true.

How do you get the preponderance of evidence?

How Preponderance of Evidence can Help You Win Your Case. If you wish to win a lawsuit, you need to have strong evidence that can prove the fault of the defendant. The court looks for strong evidence that can push the case in your favor. Your evidence should trump the oppositions.

What type of case is won by a preponderance of evidence?


Prosecutors in criminal cases must prove meet the burden of proving that the defendant is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, whereas plaintiffs in a civil case, such as for personal injury, must prove their case by a preponderance of the evidence.

What does it mean to show a preponderance of evidence?

n. the greater weight of the evidence required in a civil (non-criminal) lawsuit for the trier of fact (jury or judge without a jury) to decide in favor of one side or the other. This preponderance is based on the more convincing evidence and its probable truth or accuracy, and not on the amount of evidence.

What is clearly erroneous?

clearly erroneous - Legal Definition
n. The standard that an appellate court normally uses to review a trial judge's findings of fact when a civil case that was tried without a jury is appealed.

What are the types of evidence?

There are four types evidence by which facts can be proven or disproven at trial which include:
  • Real evidence;
  • Demonstrative evidence;
  • Documentary evidence; and.
  • Testimonial evidence.

What is a scintilla of evidence?

Scintilla of evidence rule is a common law principle that a motion for summary judgment or for directed verdict cannot be granted when there exists even the slightest amount of relevant evidence. The matter should then be tried by a jury.

What is deference law?


Deference, or judicial deference, is a principle of judicial review. In the context of administrative law, deference applies when a federal court yields to an agency's interpretation of either a statute that Congress instructed the agency to administer or a regulation promulgated by the agency.

What makes evidence circumstantial?

Circumstantial evidence is evidence that relies on an inference to connect it to a conclusion of fact—such as a fingerprint at the scene of a crime. By contrast, direct evidence supports the truth of an assertion directly—i.e., without need for any additional evidence or inference.

What is plain error review?

Plain error is an error declared by an appellate court to be patently obvious in a lower court decision or action and causes a reversal. When a defendant raises an issue on appeal that was not raised before the judge, the court of appeals may review for plain error.

What is de novo?

From Latin, meaning “from the new.” When a court hears a case de novo, it is deciding the issues without reference to any legal conclusion or assumption made by the previous court to hear the case. A trial court may also hear a case de novo following the appeal of an arbitration decision.

What does abuse of discretion mean?

Abuse of Discretion. A failure to take into proper consideration the facts and law relating to a particular matter; an Arbitrary or unreasonable departure from precedent and settled judicial custom. An improvident exercise of discretion is an error of law and grounds for reversing a decision on appeal.

What are legal standards?


Legal standards are those standards that are set forth in governmental laws. Ethical standards are based on the human principles of right and wrong. Something can be legal but not ethical. Legal standards are written by government officials, while ethical standards are written by societal norms.

What is the arbitrary and capricious standard?

Arbitrary and Capricious means doing something according to one's will or caprice and therefore conveying a notion of a tendency to abuse the possession of power. Under the "arbitrary and capricious" standard, the finding of a lower court will not be disturbed unless it has no reasonable basis.

What is an agency rule?

In administrative law, rule-making is the process that executive and independent agencies use to create, or promulgate, regulations. In general, legislatures first set broad policy mandates by passing statutes, then agencies create more detailed regulations through rulemaking.