Is oil based stain better than water based?

Asked By: Ney Bordea | Last Updated: 31st May, 2020
Category: hobbies and interests painting
4.1/5 (256 Views . 27 Votes)
Here are the advantages of using an oil-based stain: Oil-based stains are not easily penetrated by the elements. Oil-based stains dry more slowly than water-based stains and thus maintain a more even finish. Oil-based stains are far more durable than water-based stains and thus require far less maintenance.

Click to see full answer


Keeping this in consideration, is wood stain oil based?

Oil Based Stain Oil-based wood stains are the most commonly used and they are what comes to may woodworkers mind when they think of wood stain. These stains will have a linseed oil base or a mixture of linseed with varnish which gives woodworkers plenty of time to wipe off any excess before the stain dries.

One may also ask, does oil based stain protect wood? If the wood is going to be in direct exposure to wind, rain, and sunlight, an oil-based stain is the best choice. This is because it is more durable than a water-base and will provide a more complete protective layer against these elements.

Consequently, is water based polyurethane as good as oil based?

Oil-based polyurethanes leave an amber glow and require fewer coats. Both water based and oil based poly offer good protection; the biggest difference is in appearance. It's actually the most durable hardwood floor finish. If you love the natural look of maple, apply a water-based (waterborne) polyurethane.

How long does oil based stain last?

Oil-based stain can be kept for 1 year if the cans have been opened, but unopened cans will last 2 - 3 yrs. Water-based stain will last 1 year, if opened, and 2 years, if unopened.

29 Related Question Answers Found

How long does oil based stain take to dry?

Indoors: Most oil based stains will be dry to the touch in 1-2 hours and a recoat can generally be applied in roughly 2 hours. A recommended time of 8 hours (minimum) is recommended before applying a topcoat.

Is oil based stain toxic?

Oil or synthetic-based stains with acrylic or urethane binders can contain harmful chemicals and release high levels of VOCs. These stains are more water-resistant than water-based stains and are most often used outdoors.

What type of stain dries the slowest?

Oil-based wood stain is slow to dry, but once it is fully set, it lasts longer than water-based stains.

Can you put a water based stain over an oil based stain?


ANSWER: Yes! but the underlying finish has to be absolutely dry. When using a water based topcoat over an oil based stain, allow oil based finishes, such as Java Gel Stain, to dry at least 72 hours before coating with a water based topcoat. → Oil based finishes amber over time.

Is varathane wood stain oil based or water based?

Varathane Water Based Wood Stains are formulated with premium pigments for clearer color. Varathane Water Based Wood Stains have been carefully designed to have the application and handling properties of an oil based penetrating stain with the ease of soap and water clean-up and low odor.

What's the longest lasting deck stain?

Just like regular paint, solid stains hide the grain of wood, and the best should last three to five years on a deck, the longest of the three types of stains.

How many coats of water based polyurethane should I use?

We recommend a minimum of 3 coats of water based polyurethane as it coats in thinner, but harder layers, than an oil based poly. Water based polyurethane dries very quickly and up to 4 coats can be applied in one day.

Is oil based polyurethane more durable than water based?

Oil based polyurethane lasts longer than water based.
There is no contest on the durability between the 2 options. Water based polyurethane has lower VOC's - which is a bit of an environmental benefit (more about that in a moment) - but because it has lower VOC's (Volatile Organic Compounds), it doesn't last as long.

How long does water based polyurethane last?


But, if you are using a mid grade water poly (or low grade), expect the durability to be significantly lower than oil based poly. When I say lower durability, I mean that it will scratch and peel more easily and it won't last last as long (often 2 to 4 years less, but everyone's wear and tear is different).

How many coats of polyurethane should I apply?

There needs to be 3 coats of Polyurethane applied, especially if you are using an oil-based finish. The first coat should be mixed with mineral spirits. This acts as a sealer and provides a barrier between the wood and the oil finish you are using. A bristle brush is needed to apply the coats.

Can you apply oil based polyurethane with a roller?

Polyurethane is easily applied with a paint brush or roller and dries quickly. Applying the material with a roller eliminates brush strokes and lines and prevents over-applying the material. Polyurethane is available at hardware, home improvement and paint supply stores as well as online.

What is the best finish for a table top?

Varnish and oil-based poly finishes are the most durable. Tung oil and linseed oil are relatively durable. In general, it's best to stay away from shellac. Lacquer can be tough, but it tends to take on a yellow color as time goes by.

How do you make a matte finish with polyurethane?

Hand Rub With Wipe-On Varnish or Oil
If you want to transform the sheen from high gloss to satin or matte, then using a hardening oil such as tung oil is a good way to do it. Apply a base coat of gloss water- or oil-based polyurethane, let it dry and scuff it with 220-grit wet/dry sandpaper. Apply a second coat.

What happens if you don't seal stained wood?


A: If you don't apply some kind of sealer the wood will be dried-out and lifeless. A stain is intended to darken or color wood by adding pigments, but stain does not protect the wood. When you rub stain into wood, it brings out the grain pattern and gives the wood a more dramatic look.

Do you have to seal oil based stain?

And actually, the answer is YES—you can use our EMTECH water-based sealer or top coat over the oil stain. The beauty of all our water-based sealers and topcoats is that they'll level and adhere to whatever solvent- or oil-based stain you've used.

What do you seal wood with after staining?

Most stains should be sealed to prevent bleeding. After smoothing the stained wood, apply a sealer coat of thinned shellac, sanding sealer, or other appropriate sealer. Do not use shellac with NGR or water-base stains. If you plan to finish the piece with polyurethane, make sure the sealer is compatible.